S5.2.5.3, S5.2.5.4 and S5.2.5.8: Aligning Inverter Protection With Ride-Through Requirements

S5.2.5.3 and S5.2.5.4 are the clauses of Schedule 5.2 that set how far frequency and voltage at the connection point can move, and for how long, while a generating system must stay connected. S5.2.5.8 sets what protection the plant may have to disconnect itself from power system disturbances. The three have to be read together, because the commonest way to fail the first two is a protection setting allowed by the third.

These clauses look like the easy part of a Generator Performance Standard (GPS). Most inverter-based plants claim the automatic access standard for both. The work is in proving it, and in making every protection element in the plant agree.

Frequency Disturbance Withstand (S5.2.5.3)

The automatic access standard requires continuous uninterrupted operation across the frequency ranges defined in the frequency operating standard for the region:

  • indefinitely within the normal operating frequency band
  • for at least the recovery time between the normal band and the operational frequency tolerance band
  • for at least the stabilisation time between the operational tolerance band and the extreme frequency excursion tolerance limits

The plant must also ride through rates of change of frequency of up to 4 Hz per second for 0.25 seconds and 3 Hz per second for one second. The minimum access standard is narrower, using a transient frequency limit of 47.5 Hz for 9 seconds on the low side.

Because the bands are defined by reference to the frequency operating standard, they change when the Reliability Panel revises it. Check which version applies when you prepare the study. Islanded and system restoration conditions use wider bands than normal conditions, and the widest band applies.

Voltage Disturbance Withstand (S5.2.5.4)

The automatic access standard requires continuous uninterrupted operation when a disturbance external to the plant moves the voltage on one or more phases at the connection point within these ranges:

Connection point voltageAutomatic access standard: stay connected for at leastMinimum access standard
Marginally above 130%0.02 secondsNot required
Over 125% to 130%0.2 secondsNot required
Over 120% to 125%2 secondsNot required
Over 115% to 120%20 seconds0.1 seconds
Over 110% to 115%20 minutes0.9 seconds
90% to 110%ContinuouslyContinuously, subject to voltage to frequency ratio limits
Below 90% down to 80%10 seconds5 seconds
Below 80% down to 70%2 seconds2 seconds

Times run from the moment the voltage first leaves the 90% to 110% band. Below 70% the plant is in fault ride-through territory, covered by S5.2.5.5 and S5.2.5.5A.

For connections below 66 kV with no automatic tap-changing transformer between the plant and the connection point, the NSP and AEMO may agree to measure voltage at the nearest point of 66 kV or above. This can make a large difference for distribution-connected plant.

How the Clauses Are Studied

Both clauses are normally studied by playing a defined frequency or voltage profile into the connection point from an ideal source, with no grid impedance, so the plant sees exactly the profile the clause describes.

Withstand Study Cases

  • Frequency: ramps to each band edge at the maximum rate of change, held slightly longer than the required duration, then returned
  • Frequency: cases inside the deadband and at the extreme limits, at maximum, minimum and near-zero output, and charging for a BESS
  • Voltage: steps to each band in the table, held slightly beyond the required time, from a typical pre-disturbance voltage
  • Voltage: operating points at the reactive capability corners, because overvoltage while already supplying reactive power is the hardest case
  • Protection verification: profiles pushed just past each protection threshold to show the trip happens where, and only where, intended

Holding each case a little longer than the clause requires shows margin. Pushing beyond the thresholds shows the protection works. Both belong in the report.

Where Protection Comes In (S5.2.5.8)

The plant contains protection at several levels, and every one of them has voltage and frequency elements that could trip it.

LocationTypical elementsWhy it matters for withstand
InverterOver and under voltage, over and under frequency, RoCoF, sometimes vector shiftMeasures at the inverter terminals, not the connection point
Power plant controllerTrip or run-back logic on measured connection point quantitiesCan disconnect the whole plant
Connection point or main protection relayVoltage, frequency, anti-islanding, intertripOften set by the NSP's standard
Auxiliary systemsUndervoltage on cooling, control power, UPSLoss of auxiliaries can trip the plant indirectly

Three reconciliation problems come up repeatedly.

Terminal voltage is not connection point voltage. Inverter protection measures at the inverter terminals. When the plant is supplying reactive power, the terminal voltage sits above the connection point voltage, sometimes by several percent. A 130% event at the connection point can therefore be well above 130% at the terminals. The study must translate each connection point band to terminal voltage through the collector network, at the reactive operating points that make it worst, and confirm the inverter settings sit outside.

Timers that accumulate. Some protection elements accumulate time across repeated excursions. A plant can ride through each band individually and still trip when two excursions occur close together.

Settings that drift from the GPS. The settings in the OEM's default configuration, the settings in the PSCAD model, the settings in the protection settings report and the settings the GPS assumes are four different documents. Reviewers check them against each other, and a plant that trips early in simulation, compared with its declared settings, gets flagged.

What S5.2.5.8 typically allows

The negotiated S5.2.5.8 standard usually lists the conditions under which the plant may disconnect itself without breaching its other standards:

  • outside the withstand bands of S5.2.5.3 and S5.2.5.4
  • by anti-islanding or intertrip schemes required by the NSP
  • by protection under S5.2.5.9 and S5.2.5.10
  • by an emergency frequency control scheme

Plant above a size threshold must also have an automatic over-frequency droop that reduces output as frequency approaches the upper extreme limits. That function must be coordinated with the frequency control settings under S5.2.5.11.

The 2025 access standards rule also moved the requirement about voltage phase angle changes, which used to be its own clause, into the protection clauses. The practical point is unchanged: vector shift or phase angle protection must not trip the plant for phase angle steps it is required to withstand. Ask the OEM for a written statement of whether such protection is fitted, because a simulation can only show that it is not modelled.

A Simple Discipline That Avoids Most Problems

Keep a single protection settings register for the plant, covering every voltage and frequency element at every level, with each setting mapped to the GPS band it must sit outside and the margin. Use it to configure the PSCAD model, check it against the protection settings report, and send it to the OEM for confirmation. Most review comments on these clauses disappear when that register exists.

For embedded generators the same logic applies to anti-islanding settings, which must sit outside the ride-through envelope while staying sensitive to real islands. See protection coordination for embedded generators.

Get the Withstand Clauses Closed Cleanly

ElectraGlobe runs frequency and voltage withstand studies, reconciles inverter and plant protection against the GPS, and prepares the protection settings reports NSPs review. See our AEMO GPS applications service, or contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions

What voltage range must a generator ride through under S5.2.5.4?

Under the automatic access standard, from 70% of nominal voltage for 2 seconds and 80% for 10 seconds, up to 110% to 115% for 20 minutes, 115% to 120% for 20 seconds, 120% to 125% for 2 seconds, 125% to 130% for 0.2 seconds, and marginally above 130% for 0.02 seconds. Between 90% and 110% it must operate continuously.

What frequency range must a generator ride through under S5.2.5.3?

The ranges and times defined in the frequency operating standard for the region, from the normal operating band out to the extreme frequency excursion tolerance limits, together with rates of change of frequency up to 4 Hz per second for 0.25 seconds and 3 Hz per second for one second.

Why do inverters trip inside the voltage withstand bands?

Usually because inverter protection measures voltage at the inverter terminals, which can be several percent higher than the connection point voltage when the plant is supplying reactive power. Settings that look compliant at the connection point can be too tight at the terminals.

What does S5.2.5.8 cover?

Protection that disconnects a generating system in response to power system disturbances. The performance standard records the conditions under which the plant may disconnect, such as operation outside the withstand bands, anti-islanding or intertrip schemes, and emergency frequency control schemes, and includes an automatic over-frequency output reduction for larger plant.

AEMO GPS Applications

Generator Performance Standard approvals under NER Chapter 5 and 5A.

Learn more