A steady-state study for an embedded generator is the load flow analysis a distribution network service provider (DNSP) requires before it will agree an export limit for a solar farm or battery on its feeder. It checks thermal loading, voltage rise, voltage fluctuation when output changes or the plant trips, and the interaction between the plant's reactive power control and the network's tap changers and voltage regulators. For connections of 1 to 5 MW, it is usually the study that decides how much the plant can export and which network works it has to pay for.
It is also the study that gates the others. Several DNSPs will not review the dynamic, power quality or protection studies until the steady-state study has been accepted, so a slow review loop here delays the whole program.
What the DNSP Provides
The DNSP's study pack sets the ground rules. It typically contains:
- network models for peak load and light (minimum) load, in the DNSP's preferred load flow tool
- the network configurations to assess, usually system normal plus credible alternatives such as an alternate zone substation transformer, or supply from an adjacent feeder through a normally open point
- the assessment criteria, with feeder-specific voltage limits
- requirements for how the plant is to be modelled
The plant is normally modelled as a static generator with its active power limits and reactive power control mode, connected through its transformers and cables to the connection point. DNSPs check the conversion of transformer data from the manufacturer's sheets, so show the working.
The Study Cases
Typical Steady-State Case Matrix
- Peak load and light load
- Each network configuration in the study pack
- Plant output at 100%, 50% and 0% (connected but not generating)
- For a battery: maximum charging as well as maximum export
- Plant trip from maximum export, and from maximum import for a battery
- Output steps representing cloud passing and market-driven changes
- A step from maximum export to maximum import, where charging is allowed
The light load, full output case usually drives voltage rise. The peak load, zero output case usually drives voltage drop and, for a battery, the charging case drives thermal loading on the zone substation transformer and the feeder.
Typical Criteria
The DNSP's study pack governs, and limits vary between DNSPs and between feeders. The table shows the kind of criteria commonly applied, as a guide to what to expect.
| Check | Typical criterion | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Thermal loading | Equipment loading within a planning limit, often around 90% of rating | Design temperature of overhead lines matters, see below |
| Voltage rise | Small rise at the regulated bus attributable to the plant, often around 1% | Or no worsening where limits are already exceeded |
| Voltage range | Within the feeder's planning limits | Feeder-specific; often stated as a range of steady-state voltage |
| Cloud-pass fluctuation | Change of a few percent, often around 3%, for output falling from 100% to lower levels with taps locked | Represents fast irradiance changes |
| Market step | Similar limit for full output to zero and back | Price-driven ramps on battery and solar plant |
| Plant trip | Larger step allowed, often around 5%, for a trip from full output | Taps locked, immediately after the event |
| Tap changers and regulators | Not driven to their limits | Check zone substation and line regulators |
Steps are assessed with taps locked, because the voltage change customers see happens before the tap changer responds.
Power Factor or Voltage Droop
The plant's reactive power control is the main lever for keeping voltage in limits, and the steady-state study is where the setting is chosen.
Fixed power factor is simple and predictable. An absorbing power factor, slightly below unity, offsets the voltage rise caused by export. The trade-off is that a fixed absorbing power factor draws reactive power even when the feeder voltage does not need it, which widens the voltage range and can increase losses.
Voltage droop adjusts reactive power with local voltage. It can achieve lower voltage rise with less reactive absorption on average, but it interacts with tap changers, and DNSPs scrutinise it more closely.
A sensible method is to sweep the setting at light load: find the voltage rise at 100% output with taps free, then find the fluctuation for an output drop with taps locked, and choose the setting that meets the rise limit with the smallest range and fluctuation. Tightening the voltage rise usually widens the range, so the choice is a balance, not an optimum.
The Tap Interaction Test
Some DNSPs require a specific test for any plant that controls voltage or reactive power, whatever the mode:
- Solve peak load with the plant at low output and taps free to move.
- Carry the resulting tap positions over to light load with the plant at full output, and solve.
- Lock the taps and trip the plant.
- Measure the voltage change at nearby buses against the step limit.
The test captures the worst realistic combination: taps that settled for one condition, a plant that has moved the voltage a long way, and a sudden loss of the plant before the taps can respond. A plant that passes every other check can fail this one.
Design Temperature and Augmentation
Where a feeder section overloads, the usual remedy is reconductoring, and the design temperature chosen for the new conductor has a large effect on cost. A common review comment is that a study specified a higher design temperature than needed. Run the DNSP's standard design temperatures and choose the lowest that passes. Name the existing conductor correctly; copying conductor names from another project is a reliable way to lose a review round.
Other outcomes commonly agreed at this stage include:
- reduced export in prior-outage or alternate configurations
- disconnection in configurations far from normal
- no grid charging, or limited charging, where transformer or line loading is tight
- a local runback scheme tied to zone substation transformer temperature or loading
Each becomes an entry in the connection access standard. Our guide to Chapter 5A connection access standards explains how.
What Reviewers Commonly Raise
Most steady-state review comments are about presentation and consistency rather than method.
- Read voltage at the right node. A bus beyond an in-service line voltage regulator does not see the plant's rise unless the regulator is at its tap limit. State regulator status and tap positions.
- Check every phase-to-phase voltage. On feeders with single-phase regulators, the three phase-to-phase voltages can differ materially. Report the worst, not just one.
- Show before and after. Pre-connection and post-connection values side by side.
- Use words for reactive power. State supplying or absorbing, not leading or lagging, especially for a battery that changes direction.
- Plausible taps. Identical tap positions across peak, light, plant on and plant off cases look like a modelling error.
- Plausible steps. Identical voltage changes for different power steps are a red flag.
- Consistent limits. Export and import limits must match between the tables, the summary and the draft access standard, with the derivation of each configuration's limit explained.
- Control mechanics. How runbacks are shared between inverters, whether there is a power plant controller, and where the droop is measured. Droop at the connection point without a plant controller will be questioned.
Steady-State Report Checklist
- Network models and configurations as listed in the DNSP study pack, with the version stated
- Transformer and cable data conversions shown
- Pre-connection and post-connection results for every case
- Regulator and tap changer status reported for every case
- All three phase-to-phase voltages assessed where relevant
- Fluctuation and trip cases run with taps locked
- Tap interaction test completed for voltage or reactive controlled plant
- Power factor or droop setpoint, base and limits stated
- Export and import limits per configuration consistent with the draft access standard
- SLD showing connection point, point of common coupling and line distances
Get Your Steady-State Study Accepted First Time
The steady-state study sets the commercial shape of a small connection, so it repays care. ElectraGlobe runs DNSP steady-state studies, selects power factor and droop settings, and works through review comments for embedded solar and BESS projects.
See our grid connection studies service, our guide to what documents a DNSP needs, or contact us.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a DNSP steady-state study check?
Thermal loading of network equipment, voltage rise and voltage range on the feeder, voltage fluctuation for output changes and plant trips, and the interaction of the plant's reactive power control with tap changers and voltage regulators, across peak and light load and each network configuration in the study pack.
What voltage fluctuation limits apply to embedded generators?
They are set by the DNSP's study pack and vary by network. Limits of around 3% for cloud-pass and market-driven output changes, and around 5% for a plant trip, are common, assessed with tap changers locked.
Should a small solar farm use power factor or voltage droop control?
Either can work. A fixed absorbing power factor is simple and predictable; voltage droop can reduce average reactive absorption but interacts with tap changers and draws closer scrutiny. The steady-state study is used to choose the mode and setting that meet the voltage rise limit with the smallest range and fluctuation.
What is the tap interaction test?
A test some DNSPs require for voltage or reactive controlled plant. Tap positions from a low output peak load case are carried over to a full output light load case, the taps are locked and the plant is tripped. The resulting voltage change must stay within the step limit.